Which car should you choose? Comparative analysis of two models from a German manufacturer. What is more expensive to maintain - BMW or Audi? Which is still better: Audi or BMW

For quite a long time, two of the world's largest manufacturers car BMW and AUDI are competing to dominate the automotive market today.

The vehicles produced by these companies are considered to be among the best cars in their homeland - in Germany, as well as around the world.

Comparative analysis of the capabilities and technical characteristics of the Audi 200 and BMW 735i E32

To quickly and easily figure out which is better than an Audi or a BMW, you need to conduct a kind of analysis of their functional data.

Both cars were produced in the late 80s and early 90s. They are distinguished by high indicators of reliability and comfort, and are equipped with a wide range of equipment.

Let's try to compare them specifications:

  1. The propulsion system of cars. The AUDI engine has good performance in terms of power, torque and RPM. Power BMW unit 735 wins on the indicated indicators by a small margin. However, in terms of acceleration and speed development on the road, the Audi 200 is still in the lead. This is due to the undeniable quality all-wheel drive Quattro possessed this car, as well as the fact that it is somewhat lighter in total weight.
  2. Body. The famous 735i has a signature design BMW brands- aggressive appearance with clearly marked lines, extended phase and rounded headlights. The body assembly is of high quality, which provides excellent sound insulation in the cabin. AUDI also has a business card of its manufacturer on a standard body - a blown bumpers and arches. It should be noted that the BMW design wins in terms of aesthetic qualities.
  3. Transmission. Factory complete set cars assumes equipping the BMW 735 with a four-speed automatic gearbox with a special torque converter, and the AUDI 200 - five-speed gearbox mechanical type. Last device possesses reliable properties, especially if equipped with a certain mono drive. Drivers of both cars will have to closely monitor the condition of the tires, since this fact will largely depend on the service life of the gearbox. As for the indicators of cross-country ability, especially in winter period, unambiguously surpasses its competitor Audi.
  4. Brake system. Cars have disc brakes ventilated at the front. Since the Audi is equipped with all-wheel drive, respectively, it has brakes with increased power at the front. Otherwise, all characteristics are equal.
  5. Salon. Here you cannot specifically determine which is still better and more practical: the Audi 200 or the BMW 735. The cars have a high-quality extended configuration and good interior decoration... Another common point is the fairly large cabin space. Audi trim is made of velor or leather materials with a large number of natural wood inserts. The complete set contains climate control, an electric headlight system, heated seats and door handles etc. BMW boasts large salon, finished in leather and wood, an ergonomic and safe instrument panel, numerous service sensors.

Which is still better: Audi or BMW?

In order to finally decide, you need to familiarize yourself with a number of advantages of these models.

Several positive qualities of AUDI 200:

From all of the above, the conclusion follows: there is no single choice. The cars are approximately equal in technical characteristics, each of them has its own advantages and disadvantages in certain points. It all depends on the individual preferences of each person.

Quattro GmbH, a subsidiary of Audi AG, is located in Stuttgart, Germany. This division of the carmaker is responsible for the production of sporty and powerful. Founded in 1983, Quattro GmbH has brought many famous and legendary vehicles to the market.


It is possible that if it were not for this division of Audi, the world would never have seen such models as, and. We have collected the best 10 for you sports models produced by Audi over the past 20 years. Unfortunately, choosing a winner is not easy. We invite you to help us in this choice by voting at the end for the car that, in your opinion, deserves to lead the palm.

1. Audi R8


8. Audi RS2


In 1994 German mark presented to the public a powerful four-wheel drive small station wagon. ... The car accelerated from 0 to 100 km / h in 4.8 seconds. RS2 has been in production and demand for a long time.

9. Audi RS Q3


Equipped with a 2.5-liter five-cylinder engine with 306 hp. The engine is paired with a seven-speed automatic transmission with double clutch, which distributes the torque using Quattro systems on all four wheels. Thanks to the power and tuning of all components, the engineers managed to create a crossover that can accelerate from 0-100 km / h in 5.5 seconds.

10. Audi Q7 V12 TDI


Not a typical car that would attract Quattro GmbH specialists. But, nevertheless, the engineers of the Audi tuning division decided to create a special diesel version crossover Q7, which should have amazed fans diesel engines Audi and. As a result, the specialists installed a 12-cylinder turbocharged diesel engine with a capacity of 490 hp on the Audi Q7.

But the engineers decided to change not only the traditional powertrains installed on the Q7, but also other SUV systems. So the tires were upgraded, wheel disks, suspension, brakes and more, which actually made this model a completely different car with a different spirit and ambition.

You can argue endlessly about which car is better, especially when it comes to brands as close in spirit as BMW and Audi. We have already considered on our website the question - what better bmw or Mercedes, but they could not come up with a clear answer.

Judging by the various ratings, then in them in equally cars of one brand or another fall, so that this indicator is not objective. In addition, any manufacturer sometimes produces more than successful models like BMW X5 and X6, or less successful ones - BMW convertible The E46 M3, which was warmly received by the public, but the slow and overly heavy SMG gearbox ruined the entire Divine Chariot experience.

Audi has similar examples. For example, the hatchback Audi A2, which appeared in 2000. It was first positioned as an environmentally friendly clean car with frugal diesel engine and a lightweight aluminum body. However, later it turned out that the fuel consumption is not at all consistent environmental standards, and the body made of aluminum is almost impossible to repair.

Based on this, consider the strengths and weaknesses of both brands.

Audi - pros and cons

First of all, Audi is available in both front-wheel drive and all-wheel drive versions. Especially noteworthy is the corporate full Quattro drive which allows heavier cars such as the Audi A4 Allroad quattro, demonstrate excellent chassis and dynamic characteristics... At the same time, it can compete with the same BMW 328i Gran Turismo, whose engine is more powerful by as much as 20-25 hp.

It is worth saying that in the transfer Top Gear similar tests were carried out, albeit on charged versions of the RS. As a result, the heavier Audi S4 was able to outpace the BMW M3 by a full second. It should be said that in all other parameters the cars were on an equal footing.

Such moments also attract buyers to Audi:

  • external and internal design - quality materials are used, ergonomics on high level, comfort;
  • adaptive suspension which can work in different modes- from Comfort to Sport +;
  • moderate fuel consumption, although if we are talking about cars of classes D or E, then more than 10 liters can go around the city.

The only drawbacks are high prices. These machines are not for poor people.

BMW - advantages and disadvantages

BMW for the most part go either with rear wheel drive, or with a plug-in front. That is, you need to get used to them. The suspension can be quite stiff - you will feel almost every bump, especially when riding in Comfort mode. However, an advantage can be called the presence of adaptive hydraulic suspension, respectively, when driving at speeds and in Sport mode, all the holes are simply "swallowed".

Aggressive character - no one will argue with the fact that both inside and outside these cars look quite aggressive. This is their trick, and that is why they were so fond of in their time by the local "new Russian" in the dashing nineties. It is difficult, for example, to imagine some respectable burgher family using the BMW X5 as family car... But Audi is quite suitable for this role.

Prices are certainly not the lowest, so serious breakdowns are extremely rare. But if we compare with Audi, then BMW engines they do not differ in efficiency. Although if you take almost the same class of BMW 3 Series and Audi A4 Avant ( family station wagon), BMW consumes a whole liter less in the combined cycle.

Driver reviews

Dr Diesel shares his opinion:

“This is a question of expediency, I bought my first Audi A100 back in 1991, and after that I could not get used to either the French Peugeot-Renault and Fiat, their brother, or to the Korean cars. I had and japanese jeeps- they have enough of their own pluses. Now I'm thinking about doing motorsport, I tried the X5 on test drives. I believe that he can compete with Audi, as sport car».

Audi Fan:

“Audi is closer to me in its ideology - the optimal car for all occasions. But I also like BMWs, although they are overly aggressive. Why, for example, in the X series such a massive torpedo? Purely for show-off? "

“I have a simple opinion - both of these brands are worthy of each other. The only competitors. You can argue until wheezing. I personally went to both those and others - each has its own flavor, to which you need to get used to. "

You can still enumerate many similar statements, but one thing is clear - each car has its pros and cons. When choosing, you need to focus on your personal feelings and, of course, finances.

(4 assessments, the average: 5.00 out of 5)

vodi.su

What is more expensive to maintain - BMW or Audi?

In order to understand this issue, it is necessary to decide which models are to be compared. Both German brands adhere to standards the highest quality, have their own traditions of the automotive industry, therefore all models of a particular brand have certain general characteristics, style and so on.

Compare old budget model Audi with new bmw a prestige class would be inappropriate and inappropriate. For the convenience of comparing the maintenance of brands, we will select the corresponding models in terms of class, functionality and popularity - BMW "three" and Audi "four".

To begin with, both manufacturers have tried to provide their vehicles with maximum corrosion resistance.

Frame, chassis, all mechanics do not rust for a very long time, so you can safely purchase cars of both brands if you plan to operate them in difficult climatic conditions... Note that Audi cars sometimes have problems with corrosion of the wiper drive, but repairing it is not expensive, so it is not a serious argument in terms of cost savings.

In their latest lines, Audi cars are equipped with a richer interior trim, and therefore require appropriate care. Any damage to the cladding entails quite tangible costs for replacing expensive material, although salons BMW cars high cost interior decoration are not much inferior.

Car owners feel a big financial expense in the event of engine problems. Most often, Audi's thermostats and compressors fail on subcompact engines, diesel engine lines are not reliable enough. However, gasoline engines break very rarely. Bavarian engines extremely durable, designed for big runs, but even here it is not without problems, because often on turbodiesels they require repair of the turbine and fuel injectors.

Both brands have problems with automatic boxes transmissions while modifications with "mechanics" are very successful. Not much, but inferior to Audi in the strength of its chassis, braking system, electronics and suspensions.

BMW requires a special approach to the use of oils. Only the highest quality and highest quality expensive brands otherwise, problems arise in the gearbox, engine and other systems.

There is no single answer to this question, since a lot depends on the configuration and modification, driving style, operating conditions and other factors.

In general, we can conclude that Audi cars in most of their parameters are less reliable and often require repair, but this is more than offset by the fact that maintenance and repair of Audi is less expensive, ranging from Supplies and ending with the cost of failed spare parts. Moreover, the availability of all components for Audi, both on the primary and on secondary market, wins.

When choosing a car, it is advisable to initially assess the expected load on the car: how often it is planned to drive, for what distances, on what roads and in what climatic conditions. You need to understand that the differences in the highest quality brands are quite insignificant, therefore, for repairs as BMW cars and Audi are relatively rare. Considering this aspect, from a financial point of view, it is preferable to look Audi models, since in working order they require less expensive "consumables", and in case of breakdowns - less expensive spare parts.

Our technical center Audi NIVUS conducts Maintenance and elimination of breakdowns of Audi cars, while we are especially attentive to the prevention of damage, we provide the driver with advice and recommendations on the most effective use of his model, we focus on the strong and weaknesses each specific machine.

audi.nivus.ru

BMW vs AUDI: which is more expensive to maintain?

BMW cars and AUDI are in equally high demand, and many car owners are interested in which of these cars will be cheaper to maintain. However, it is impossible to unequivocally answer this question, since each brand has many different models, which differ in parameters, and the price of the service also depends on many factors. Nevertheless, we made a conditional comparison and came to the following conclusions.

The main factors affecting the cost of BMW and AUDI service

  • The age of the cars. It's no secret that the older the car, the more expensive its maintenance will be. Both BMW and AUDI suffer from chronic ailments. In Audi, for example, thermostats and compressors on cars with small engines often fail. German units are generally more reliable, but diesel engines often break turbines, which entails considerable costs. Estimated costs for parts can be estimated here: http://rextor.ru/catalogs
  • Mode and operating conditions. Maintenance costs depend on how intensively the car is used and on what roads it has to drive. However, to the credit of the Bavarians, be it said, BMW can withstand much more significant suspension loads, while Audi can fail after the first 50 thousand kilometers.
  • Transmission type. Both in Audit and BMW, the most unpretentious and "unkillable" is the mechanical transmission, it can serve for years without causing any trouble. As for the automatic box, both manufacturers often cause trouble for the owners, since technical unit needs more careful maintenance, especially if the driving is not very careful.
  • Timeliness of service. For both BMW and Audi typical problem is the absence of symptoms of breakage in the early stages. The units are very reliable, therefore they may not show signs of failure for a long time, therefore, irregular service can cause increased costs.

And yet, which car is cheaper to maintain?

Summing up, the following conclusions can be drawn. BMWs are cars that are generally more reliable and more durable than Audi. They break less often, but in the event of a malfunction, spare parts will turn out to be much more expensive.

At Audi, all technical units are less durable and fail faster. However, the parts themselves are cheaper, easier to find, and available. wide choose non-original spare parts, which compensates for the lack. Therefore, both cars will generally cost about the same in maintenance.

Similar articles:

drivee.ru

Choosing the best car brand: Audi or Mercedes-Benz?

For more than a decade, Russians have been using the services of the foreign car industry, which, naturally, occurs due to the creation of such large concerns like Mercedes and Audi, very high quality and efficient Vehicle who are able to prove themselves as reliable and loyal for a long time iron horse, always ready to help its master. However, in order to decide which brand of car is better to prefer the modern consumer, you will have to, at least, get acquainted with the technical characteristics of the presented cars.

It is quite simple to compare the cars of such large organizations as Mercedes and Audi, because they are rightfully considered the largest German giants, producing spectacular and at the same time efficient cars in operation. German car industry is a leader among typical organizations... Remarkable is the fact that the value of vehicles belonging to both Mercedes as well as Audi, fluctuates at almost the same level.

For a more detailed analysis, we will consider the technical characteristics of the machines, their internal comfort and, importantly, safety. When choosing a vehicle, you should not rely solely on personal preferences, which is why we will find out the opinion of experts and get acquainted with the level of sales German cars v different countries the world. Do not neglect the title of "Best Car of the Year", which is awarded annually to one or another car brand.

Globally recognized auto

Like any other field, the automotive industry is subject to rigorous scrutiny by experienced experts, whose opinion often has crucial... For more than one year, people from all countries have been uniting to choose really the vehicle that is an order of magnitude better than the others released this year.

For example, according to the results of the past 2015 of the year Mercedes-Benz The C-category, which was nominated for the New York Motor Show, became the undisputed leader. It should be noted that among the cars with which it competed, one could see the BMW 2 Series, new volkswagen Passat B8 (improved), Nissan Qashqai and Mazdu 2.

The second competition held within the United States also did not bypass Mercedes, a leading place among the best sports cars of the year received a Mercedes AMG-GT. The main contenders for this place were two Audi models: Audi TT and Audi S3.

However, and this is not all, Mercedes has proven itself well in the European nomination “A Car of the Year”. Despite the fact that the first place with 248 points was taken by the Citroen C4 Cactus, the Mercedes C-class, gaining 221 points, left behind its fellow Audi.

What is noteworthy, in 2015, cars produced by the Audi concern did not even manage to get into the top five world leaders. True, this did not affect the demand for Audi cars in Russia. Compatriot motorists do not agree with the opinion of their foreign colleagues, giving first place in the nominations the best novelty years and premium brand car Audi TT. In addition, the Audi TT is recognized as best coupe last year. As for the Mercedes S-category, the Russians awarded him the title of the best executive car.

An interesting fact is that the best car of 2015 was UZ Daewoo matiz. Domestic Kalina Cross is recognized as the most promising all-rounder with better cross-country ability... It is not known for what reasons, but this car is several points ahead of even the newfangled Audi A6 AllRoad.

If you look into the "piggy bank" of the competition "A Car of the Year", it will become known that the Europeans only once awarded Mercedes-Benz and Audi the title best cars of the year. To listen to the opinion of experts or not is an individual choice of everyone. True, even this aspect indicates that Audi and Mercedes are in the same position.

Specifications

Compare all the lineup the two richest German concerns too long and difficult, so we will carry out a comparative analysis of only the most iconic cars... Recently, organizations have shown the world presentable high-end crossovers, including:

  • Mercedes GLA with a capacity of 170 liters. sec., 220 CDI 4 Matic DCT, with a fuel consumption of 6.1 liters in the combined cycle;
  • Audi Q3 with 177 hp. sec., 2.0 TDi Quattro S Tronic and fuel consumption of 6.3 liters in the combined cycle.

The listed cars are similar in the category by the presence of an all-wheel drive, automatic transmission, typical power of diesel power units and the same fuel consumption.

Test drive of promising models

A car like Mercedes GLA has repeatedly proved the absence sufficient power, as evidenced by the presence of a huge list of competitors that can quickly bypass it even on a straight line. Fuel tank it can hold only 50 liters, this volume is enough for 800 km. In fairness, it should be noted that one refueling of an Audi car is enough for 1010 km.

However, this argument can be overridden by the fact that Mercedes is better than Audi in terms of the amount of electronics it contains and a variety of different sensors. Mercedes GLA can become an indispensable vehicle for those who wish to purchase not racing car and beautiful modern car designed mainly for long family trips.

If you do not take into account the technical characteristics, but pay attention to the dimensions of the cars, you will immediately notice a spacious and cozy salon Audi Q3, which cannot be said about its rival Mercedes. However, on the exterior, which was in second place in the previous nomination, the Mercedes car looks more confident, its aggressiveness and notes of sporty style should be noted.

After thoroughly checking all possible details, an incorruptible analysis of the capabilities of the two cars shown on the track and the cost of these vehicles, the experts put:

  • Audi 467 points (preference was given to good spaciousness, soft suspension quality power unit and efficient transmission. The decrease in points was due to the presence of a not very presentable appearance);
  • Mercedes 450 points (the excellent handling and prestige of the exterior deserve special attention. weak motor and not too spacious interior).

Despite their not the highest technical characteristics, Mercedes cars are overpriced, which not every motorist can pay.

True, when choosing a crossover, you can rather pay attention to BMW, since this type of car is precisely its prerogative. Concerns Audi and Mercedes have earned great popularity in the sale of executive sedans.

In order to understand this issue, it is necessary to decide which models are to be compared. Both German brands adhere to the highest quality standards, have their own traditions of the automotive industry, so all models of a particular brand have certain common characteristics, style, and so on.

Comparing the old budget Audi model with the new BMW prestige class would be inappropriate and impractical. For the convenience of comparing the maintenance of brands, we will select the corresponding models in terms of class, functionality and popularity - BMW "three" and Audi "four".

Comparative advantages and disadvantages

To begin with, both manufacturers have tried to provide their vehicles with maximum corrosion resistance.

The body, chassis, all mechanics do not rust for a very long time, so you can safely purchase cars of both brands if you plan to operate them in difficult climatic conditions. Note that Audi cars sometimes have problems with corrosion of the wiper drive, but repairing it is not expensive, so it is not a serious argument in terms of cost savings.

In their latest lines, Audi cars are equipped with a richer interior trim, and therefore require appropriate care. Any damage to the trim entails quite tangible costs for replacing expensive material, although BMW car interiors are not much inferior in the high cost of interior decoration.

Car owners feel a big financial expense in the event of engine problems. Most often, Audi's thermostats and compressors on small engines fail, diesel engine lines are not reliable enough. At the same time, gasoline engines rarely break down. Bavarian engines are extremely durable, designed for high mileage, but even here they are not without problems, because turbine diesel engines often require repair of turbines and fuel injectors.

Both brands have problems with automatic transmissions, while modifications with "mechanics" are very successful. Not much, but inferior to Audi in strength of its chassis, braking system, electronics and suspensions.

BMW requires a special approach to the use of oils. Only the highest quality and most expensive brands should be filled, otherwise problems arise in the gearbox, engine and other systems.

What will be cheaper in the end?

There is no single answer to this question, since a lot depends on the configuration and modification, driving style, operating conditions and other factors.

In general, we can conclude that Audi cars in most of their parameters are less reliable and often require repair, but this is more than offset by the fact that maintenance and repair of Audi is less expensive, starting from consumables and ending with the cost of failed parts. What's more, the availability of all Audi parts, both in the original and aftermarket, wins.

When choosing a car, it is advisable to initially assess the expected load on the car: how often it is planned to drive, for what distances, on what roads and in what climatic conditions. You need to understand that the differences in the highest quality brands are quite insignificant, therefore, both BMW and Audi cars are relatively rarely repaired. Considering this aspect, from a financial point of view, Audi models look preferable, since in working order they require less expensive "consumables", and in case of breakdowns - less expensive spare parts.

Our technical center Audi NIVUS carries out maintenance and repair of breakdowns of Audi cars, while we are especially attentive to the prevention of damage, provide the driver with advice and recommendations on the most effective use of his model, focus on the strengths and weaknesses of each specific car.